You, Me, and the Stump equals three!

This post is going to be in two parts. I know, I know I loath two parters too!! Ok never mind fuck that! One part! But warning it’s alittle lengthy, but you can do it, I have faith…I had wrote a packed down 5minute version of the story for Abiola’s Kiss and Tell Live, but I think it’s better with details and back-story. And thus you are stuck with a two parter long post.

SIDEBAR: This is also a story I’ve sat on for a while. I’ve struggled with on so many levels, but in the end putting it out there is always best, or not. But here we go *deep breath*

You, Me, and the Stump equals three! Part One and Two!

I had noticed Elevator-Hottie since I starting working in the building 5 months ago. Ok, I didn’t notice him I straight up stared and maybe drooled at him. This man was hot, and by hot I mean HAWT!

We always seemed to be stuck in the elevator together, most times alone no matter what time of the day.

I simply chalked this up to fate!

We had exchanged a few smiles back and forth (god he had great teeth) but other then that, he watched the elevator TV and I pretended to be doing something important on my phone while I checked out his hot ass in his nice suit!

I worked late that night and as I was leaving the office around 8pm, I clicked the down button.

The door opened and there stood his tall gorgeous frame. (If I were a guy I would’ve got an instant hard on)

He smiled. I quickly looked down at my phone.

Elevator-Hottie: Can I just say something?

I looked up, mouth open from shock and stared at his beautiful face. I did not say anything, I don’t think I even nodded, but may have turned bright red.

Elevator-Hottie: You’re gorgeous! I’d love to take you to dinner sometime, if you’d like and are available.

I keep staring, drool may or may not have fallen from my mouth.

“Ummmm…(What ever I said here was most definitely babble and I fear evening thinking about it. I’ve blocked it from my memory)

Elevator-Hottie: Can I get your card?

“Umm…yeah…sure” I fumbled for a card.

Elevator-Hottie: “I always wondered what you did at ‘the magazine with boobies’……”

His voice trailed off as he got off the elevator. I was planted firmly in my place still in shock and awe from the fact he even talked to me. ME!?! Did he just ask me out? HE asked ME, (ME?!) out!?!

The elevator doors closed!

SIDEBAR: I am an idiot!

I press the button the doors open (as I am already on the first floor). I walk out he is gone and there is Tom my favorite of our night security desk guys. “Smooth, very smooth!” He says with a smile.

I blew it! I totally blew it! Oh well.

But I get a phone call that night, and it was Elevator-Hottie. Seriously, I was now staring to believe in this ‘fate’ stuff.

Our first date was to be an after work drink. Although in all honesty I didn’t go to work till the end of day cause I was picking out the perfect outfit, getting my hair just right, doing nails, and all the girl (yes sometimes I’m like that) stuff!

We had a seemingly perfect first date. We had great conversation, I didn’t get to drunk (a usual first date flaw on my part) we ended up grabbing dinner, all in all a great date. As we were saying our goodbyes he gave me a “had a great time” accompanied by a pat on the shoulder.

He hates me. Maybe I shouldn’t have had that third drink, maybe I talked to much, I probably swore to much, maybe it’s cause I made fun of him…..urg such is my life!

But he called me. And he kept calling me.

Now Elevator-Hottie was everything you’d want in a man, especially in a Manhattan man. Tall, unbelievable handsome, very well educated, good family, owned his own apartment with a park view (and not stand on the toilet  in the bathroom tilt your head kind of view, we’re talking a view!) He had great job, and he even a summer house.

Date number 12 rolls around and the most action I’ve gotten is a peck on the lips and a pat on the back hug. And a few flower arrangements sent to my office.

I mean come on, a girl cant wait forever. In my dating world 12 dates is pretty much an engagement! So you better pony up! I was so confused by the situation, and never been in one like this before. Plus, I like sex so I was alittle upset on that front too.

I was also struggling with him because as perfect on paper as he may have been. He really didn’t make me laugh. OK, I shouldn’t say that he was funny he would make any normal girl laugh alot. But I need and want a guy who makes me spit out my drink, maybe pee my pants just alittle bit laugh! (It’s a requirement)

My friends all pushed me towards the ‘perfect on paper’ and said to ignore the other details.

Oh right, I’m forgetting that one other detail. You see for all his great perfect on paper points, there’s one little thing he didn’t have.

One quality mister-perfect-elevator-hottie-on-paper was missing.

Actually, it was more of an appendage then a quality. You see Elevator-Hottie was missing his left leg below the knee. He had a prosthetic, no leg, a whatever you want to call it………There was no leg!

So I rationalized his lack of physical contact as a shyness of his stump.

Maybe it was all scared up and nasty! Maybe it was shaped funny. Maybe he was scared I’d want to lick it during foreplay.

All I knew was if he didn’t take my pants off on this our 14th date, it’s over.

Leg or no leg : Over!

I get a Text message: Instead, why don’t you come over and we’ll order in and watch a movie.

Thank you Jesus! Come over and watch a movie IS and has always been code for come over and have sex!

But now I was terrified. I frantically spent hours googling sex with one legged men, and so on. These results turned up nothing but scary porn, and creepy craigslist ads.

This was it. You see if the sex is amazing, I guess I can get over the lack of gut hurting laugher. Plus, I was starting to really like him. NowI was more nervous then excited.

I show up at his apartment. I walk in the door and he jumps me. Wow! Like throws me against the wall, jumps me.

Where did this guy come from?

Lips are intertwined, arms are throwing and ripping off clothes. This one legged Hottie was on a mission! And his mission was me!

We take this action into the bedroom. We’re doing it, and we’re doing it. Oh and we’re doing it! And it was really great. And did I mention the view of the park from the bedroom!? The whole thing was hot and amazing!

I’m in the moment. Really in the moment, and then he decides he wants to take a trip…downtown !

And as I lay there with my eyes closed enjoying his downtown adventure I hear a soft whisper in my ear.

“She’s good isn’t she.”

I look over. I look down. I look over. I look down. I look…I look DOWN!

And there between my legs is this mass of grey hair.

I jump back! So fast and hard I hit the headboard and the back of my head started to bleed.

There at the foot of the bed is this …..Old Lady.

Now not just old, we’re talking tales from the crept, old lady boobs to her knees, fucking Old Lady OLD!

As I’m picking up my stuff I’m speechless. More shocked then when he asked me out in the elevator. I kept looking at him and his perfect body his mouth was moving, something about it being ok, how he wants me to stay. I kept looking at her with her really not perfect body saying something about how he was right I am really pretty.

And I couldn’t say anything. Maybe it was just the surprise of it, maybe it was the feeling that I was pretty much just violated by an old woman, or maybe it’s because I hit my head so hard I was pretty sure I was dying of a brain bleed. I was shaking and in shock, and just wanting to leave.

As I ran out in my jacket, one shoe and holding everything else I came in with. I walked into the bar across the street asked where the bathroom was and said I was coming back for shots!

As I put my clothes on I held back tears. I don’t know why exactly, but I had never wanted to be more loved and cherished by a man then in that moment. It sounds odd I know, but all I could think was why couldn’t I meet a nice guy, why does every guy I meet need to be an asshole douchebag or a freak. Why won’t anyone ever just love me. What was wrong with me?

Because just when you think someone is perfect on paper you realize their grandmother is doing the book keeping from inside the closet, or under the bed, or wherever one hides a walking swinger of a corpse!

Show some love:
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • RSS

22 Comments Add Yours ↓

The upper is the most recent comment

  1. Paul #
    1

    what the fuck!! LMFAO.

  2. Nathan #
    2

    Fuck me. I thought it might have ended up just being a dream when that crazy turn happened….but it wasn’t. Damn.

  3. thrillhouse1134 #
    3

    Oh plum, how intriguing. How I enjoy living vicariously through your vagina. …wait, what?

  4. jilly-bean #
    4

    this is simply a terrible post and just shows once again how you have no morals in your life. what happened in this post is both wrong and illegal, and you ae off making fun of it like you always do. I’v esaid it before many times and I’m saying it again. I am never reading this blog again. These people need are out hurting and tricking thousands of other girls and it is no bodies fault but yours for not speaking up and not reporting this hatful and unlawful action. you should be ashamed and stoned for this!

  5. JohnnytheG #
    5

    oh my dear lord plum! I hate that I laughed at this, but at the same time how can you not!

  6. dessi #
    6

    Really? REALLY! WOW!

  7. CARL #
    7

    Scary, Funny, and great story telling. This is maybe your crown jewel under why you aren’t looking for a serious man.

  8. Jackmcmaster #
    8

    holy fucking shit! What? I had to read that over like 4 times before it really sunk in. people are messed up!

  9. Heather #
    9

    My first date question are now going to include, do you have both your legs?

  10. 10

    @jilly-bean : I don’t think getting stoned would have made it any better. The woman sounded pretty old.

  11. 11

    What….the….hell???? You seriously have to be making this up, right? There’s no way that happens in a…world. Come on….seriously?? Stop messing with me. Seriously???

  12. furfff #
    12

    I feel for ya, plum. That’s not what you signed up for.

    Jillybean? The only crime I see depicted on this page is your massacre of the english language. and quit blaming victims of crimes or people will start to think you side with criminals yourself. talk about moral dilemmas; you’re suggesting a woman should be stoned! Maybe you should get a mirror before commenting next time.

  13. michele #
    13

    holy hell! you can’t make that sh*t up. ridiculous! glad you got out in one piece :)

  14. MOLLY #
    14

    I’m still mortified over this. but I’m glad you are at a place where you can laugh about it with out it really hurting and put it out there. I know there were a few days you stayed locked up in your house. You are amazing. I am lucky to know that in person unlike most of the people who read this. This guy was an asshole douchebag! One day you will meet the man that would god forbid cut off his legs for you! Well written. Love You xo!

  15. Dave #
    15

    I’m with miss molly! I’m happy you were not only able to put this out in the world and heal from it that way, but even more proud of the fact you were able to tell this in an open setting with strangers. But again, this story is funny. I wish people could see the look on your face, in your eyes when you tell it! By far my fav “plum” sex story, and by far the worst too!

  16. 16

    Ah…
    I believe you were making a joke. Can’t quite work out the logistics of him switching with his Grandma without you noticing.

    Regardless, you made me laugh out loud, sit in shock and want to be the perfect guy for you all in one blog.

    Good times.

  17. 17

    I am partially mortified by this post. I may never have sex again. I’m gonna need to read the second half of this post… soon.

  18. 18

    I have no words Plum. No words! Horrifying and oh-so hilarious at the same time. I feel your pain. But gosh, what a story. I mean, you can’t make this shit up can you? XKB

  19. 19

    WTF .. you are f**king shitting me right ?? He was there all over you and then there was an old woman trying to go down on you ??? or peering at you ?? OMG you poor baby !!!

    I thought weird shit happened to me .. but this one takes the cake ! I’m so sorry that Hottie wasn’t Normal Hottie but more like Freaky Stumpy Hottie instead :(

    We’re gonna go do Long Islands in Bryant Park once I hit the city and try to scope out all the normal hotties and check that no old fogies live with them who will enter the bedroom !

  20. Anonymous #
    20

    holy shit. [read in the belushi style]

  21. 21

    That may be OFFICIALLY the creepiest thing I’ve ever heard…I mean…LITERALLY…I mean…of all the times you may want to overreact…this would be it…and I would have done it by calling the POLICE! um…hello…grandma just mouth raped you! That being said…maybe you should just be glad you got out of there alive because this has serial killer written all over it…and nobody wants to read the headline

    **Top Notch Blogger Found Beaten To Death By Peg Leg…Neighbors Reported Grandma Feeling The Scene** YIKES! (though sure to be hilarious is about 5 years :P)

  22. 22

    OMG, my life now seems boring! Holy Cow, LOL.



Your Comment